Transfer pricing: customs valuation cases with retroactive price adjustments
Video locked
The video is available exclusively to our members.
In this expert commentary, Mark K. Neville, Jr. (Principal, International Trade Counsellors) examines the CJEU's Tauritus judgment and what it means for customs valuation in transfer pricing cases involving retroactive price adjustments — essential viewing for customs and trade compliance professionals working with related-party pricing.
Topics covered:
- The Tauritus case: a formula-based, provisional-price (not transfer pricing) dispute, and why paragraph 60 of the judgment matters
- US legal background on formula-based pricing and post-entry rebates under the transaction value method
- The US customs reconciliation program and its use for provisional pricing and later transfer pricing studies
- A 2012 US customs ruling setting out five criteria for recognizing upward and downward compensating adjustments
- The WCO's progression of guidance: Commentary 4.1 (1982) on price review clauses, Commentary 23.1 (2010), and case studies 14.1 through 14.4 on compensating adjustments and transaction value
- How Tauritus compares with the Hamamatsu decision, including the role of advance pricing agreements (APAs) and the pre-UCC/UCC distinction
- Practical takeaways for structuring transfer pricing policies to support transaction value and post-importation price adjustments in the EU
For a broader overview of the topic, please watch the full recording. The slides are available in the Resources section.
Please note that this summary was generated using AI, based on the recording and available slides.
Related content
Customs valuation - the particularities of different countries
Customs valuation is one of the most problematic areas of customs, whatever the country or territory. Experts from different continents - from North and South America to Europe and Asia…
Valuation fall-back method - pracical insights from case law
The fallback (residual) method is the most flexible but also the most complex of the six methods for determining customs value under EU law, applied only once every other method…
CJEU: when can the cost of EU-based design work be included in customs value?
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) recently ruled on a matter with significant implications for companies importing packaged goods into the EU. When an EU-based buyer pays…
Incoterms® and case law: legal interpretation in international trade
Barbara Bonafini, a lawyer specialising in international trade and customs law, examines Incoterms® from a case-law perspective, contrasting how the Italian Supreme Court and the European Court of Justice interpret…
Incoterms® explained: UK & EU trade risks after Brexit
A UK trade expert explains how Incoterms® are used and misunderstood in UK-EU trade after Brexit, and what compliance risks customs and trade professionals need to watch for. Topics covered:…
Using export price data under the fallback method of customs valuation: lessons from CJEU
Since the start of 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union has issued two rulings focusing on the use of the fallback method for customs valuation. These decisions…