CJEU on the right to be heard: it cannot be limited by any legislative provision

Ilona Mishchenko
Ilona Mishchenko
Managing Editor, CustomsClear, Ukraine
Published 03 Dec 2023
CJEU on the right to be heard: it cannot be limited by any legislative provision
Adobe Stock
Case law
Customs law
The right to be heard is well known to practitioners from various customs decisions and the Art. 22(6) of the Union Customs Code: 'Before taking a decision which would adversely affect the applicant, the customs authorities shall communicate the grounds on which they intend to base their decision to the applicant, who shall be given the opportunity to express his or her point of view'. This fundamental right of the EU legal order is not just a formality - the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) recently annulled a regulation because it found that the European Commission had violated the importer's right to be heard during the process of adopting that regulation. It is therefore worthwhile for importers, exporters and other parties involved to take a close look at the topic and be prepared to use the right to their own advantage at EU or national level if needed.

Related content

A wrong EORI number, and the direct customs representative is held liable for the import VAT

A wrong EORI number, and the direct customs representative is held liable for the import VAT

Michael Lux
Michael Lux
13 Aug 2026

Editorial note. A direct customs representative inserts a wrong EORI number which does not belong to his client (the importer) and ends up being considered as customs representative without empowerment,…

Duties & taxes
Customs law
Topic spotlight
The ten-year anniversary of the Union Customs Code: success stories and lessons for the future

The ten-year anniversary of the Union Customs Code: success stories and lessons for the future

Juozas Šarūnas Avižienis
Juozas Šarūnas Avižienis
31 May 2026

Editorial note: The Union Customs Code celebrates its tenth anniversary this year, and its "successor" is expected to be published in the Official Journal of the European Union in the…

Customs law
Perspective
UCC changes - purpose and impact

UCC changes - purpose and impact

Anthony Buckley
Anthony Buckley
14 Jul 2026

A cluster of EU customs changes has taken effect together, and they reach well beyond e-commerce. The €150 duty exemption is gone, and a flat €3 duty now applies to…

Customs law
E-commerce
EU Customs Reform: reshaping responsibilities

EU Customs Reform: reshaping responsibilities

Massimo De Gregorio
Massimo De Gregorio
29 Jun 2026

A customs-broker expert unpacks the sanctions and liability chapter of the EU customs reform, explaining how it reshapes responsibility across the whole supply chain and what it means for customs…

Customs law
Modernising EU Customs: a perspective from the European Shippers' Council

Modernising EU Customs: a perspective from the European Shippers' Council

Godfried Smit
Godfried Smit
15 Mar 2026

In this interview, Godfried Smit, Secretary General of the European Shippers’ Council, shares his reflections on the EU Customs Reform. From the future EU Data Hub and the growing importance…

Customs law
Perspective
The new Union Customs Code (UCC)

The new Union Customs Code (UCC)

12 May 2026

Anthony Buckley, former Head of Irish Customs, explains the proposed reform of the EU Union Customs Code (UCC) to CustomsClear - essential viewing for anyone in customs and trade compliance…

Customs law