Customs penalties in Brazil: latest developments

Leonardo Macedo
Leonardo Macedo
Counsellor, Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (CARF), Brazil
Published 19 Nov 2025

Video locked

The video is available exclusively to our members.

A short presentation from CustomsClear's 30th Authors' Meeting in which Leonardo Macedo, Counsellor at Brazil's Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (CARF), unpacks a Brazilian Superior Tribunal of Justice ruling that reclassifies customs infractions as either administrative or tax-related — a distinction directly relevant to customs and trade compliance professionals working with penalty regimes and limitation periods.

Topics covered:

  • The Superior Tribunal of Justice ruling separating customs infractions into "administrative" and "tax" categories
  • The three-year administrative extinctive prescription (statute of limitations) and Brazil's two-level administrative appeal system
  • Why classification as administrative vs tax changes whether a three-year time bar applies
  • The practical challenge of reclassifying around 90 types of customs penalties before the ruling enters into force
  • Knock-on effects of the classification for tax collection, administrative enforcement, and criminal/penal liability
  • Whether similar administrative-vs-tax classification dilemmas may arise in other jurisdictions

For a broader overview of the topic, please watch the full recording. The slides are available in the Resources section.

Please note that this summary was generated using AI, based on the recording and available slides.

Related content

The most unexpected customs risk that businesses faced

The most unexpected customs risk that businesses faced

Muitinės praktikų asociacija
Muitinės praktikų asociacija
18 Nov 2021

Is it possible for the business to consider all the possible customs-related risks? The answer to the poll question was unambiguous. All participants of the 8th Authors' Meeting on 21.10.2021…

Compliance
Topic spotlight
The main fines for customs infringements in Brazil

The main fines for customs infringements in Brazil

Roberto Raya da Silva
Roberto Raya da Silva
08 Aug 2020

We overview fines in Brazil for customs infringements, focusing on the fines imposed as a consequence of incorrect classification and description of goods, and pointing out the importance of voluntary…

Compliance
Topic spotlight
Why EU customs penalties need harmonisation

Why EU customs penalties need harmonisation

Walter Van der Meiren
Walter Van der Meiren
07 Dec 2025

Fragmentation in how EU member states enforce customs penalties undermines fairness and predictability across the customs union - this talk sets out why harmonised administrative sanctions matter for compliance professionals…

Compliance
Out of temperature, out of liability? A case on freight responsibility

Out of temperature, out of liability? A case on freight responsibility

Omer Wagner
Omer Wagner
16 Apr 2026

A shipment of industrial adhesive was stored at the wrong temperature resulting in damage (it was stored at minus 20 degrees instead of 20 degrees). The insurance company compensated the…

Compliance
Case law
Criminal or civil? How the US handles customs violations

Criminal or civil? How the US handles customs violations

Mark K. Neville, Jr.
Mark K. Neville, Jr.
19 Nov 2025

Mark K. Neville, Jr. (International Trade Counsellors) explains the three regimes the United States uses to enforce customs violations, and why enforcement focus is now shifting, which is directly relevant…

Compliance
Mapping customs penalties accross EU

Mapping customs penalties accross EU

Antonio Castagnini
Antonio Castagnini
18 Nov 2025

Customs penalties are not harmonised across the EU: this conference presentation by Antonio Castagnini (Greif) maps how the 27 member states differ in treating customs violations as administrative or criminal…

Compliance
Profession